Shopify App Comparison 2026
Monk Free Gift BOGO & Upsell
Giftship: Gift Options & More
Which Shopify upsell app increases AOV more? Compare pricing, features, ratings & real merchant reviews for Monk and Giftship: Gift Options & More to find the best fit for your store.
Free gift with purchase, BOGO & checkout upsells
View Full DetailsKey Features
- Free gift with purchase based on cart value or product rules
- BOGO (Buy One Get One) and Buy X Get Y promotions
- Checkout and post-purchase upsell offers
- Cart progress bar to encourage higher spending
- Tiered gift offers with multiple reward thresholds
Verdict on Monk
Monk is an excellent all-in-one solution for merchants who want free gifts, BOGO deals, and upsells in a single app. Its tiered reward system and cart progress bar are particularly effective at nudging customers to spend more.
One app for gifting options, box builders, upsells & checkout
View Full DetailsKey Features
- Gift wrap, gift messages, and greeting card options
- Multi-address shipping for sending gifts to multiple recipients
- Custom gift box builder for curated gift sets
- Delivery date picker with scheduling support
- Checkout upsells and order add-ons
Verdict on Giftship:
Giftship is the most comprehensive gifting app on Shopify. If your store sells gift-oriented products and you need multi-address shipping, box builders, and premium gift options, Giftship is the clear winner despite a slightly higher price.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I set up multiple gift tiers based on cart value?
Yes, Monk supports tiered gifting where you can offer different gifts at different cart value thresholds, such as a small gift at $50 and a premium gift at $100.
Does the app work with Shopify checkout extensions?
Yes, Monk supports Shopify checkout extensibility for upsells and gift offers directly within the checkout flow, compatible with Shopify Plus and standard plans.
Will the free gift be auto-added to the cart?
Yes, you can configure Monk to automatically add the free gift to the customer's cart once the qualifying conditions are met, creating a seamless experience.
Can customers ship to multiple addresses in a single order?
Yes, Giftship supports multi-address shipping where customers can send individual items to different recipients within one order, complete with personalized messages for each.
Does Giftship include a gift box builder?
Yes, the Professional plan includes a custom gift box builder that lets customers select products to assemble their own curated gift set with wrapping and messaging options.
Can I attach a greeting card to gift orders?
Yes, Giftship supports greeting card attachments on the Professional plan. Customers can write a personal message that gets printed or included as a digital card with the order.