Shopify App Comparison 2026
Printify: Print on Demand
CustomCat Print on Demand
Which Shopify upsell app increases AOV more? Compare pricing, features, ratings & real merchant reviews for Printify: and CustomCat Print on Demand to find the best fit for your store.
Create and sell custom products, we handle the rest
View Full DetailsKey Features
- Network of 80+ print providers worldwide for competitive pricing
- Over 900 customizable products from apparel to home decor
- Built-in product design editor with text, images, and patterns
- Automatic order routing to your chosen print provider
- Free shipping options available on select products
Verdict on Printify:
Printify stands out for its multi-provider marketplace model, which lets merchants compare prices and choose the best fulfillment partner for each product. This flexibility often results in lower base costs than single-provider platforms. The free tier is feature-rich, and the Premium plan pays for itself quickly through product discounts.
Print on demand with 550+ products and 3-day production time
View Full DetailsKey Features
- Over 550 products with DTG, sublimation, and embroidery options
- Average 3-day production turnaround from US-based facility
- Own production facility in Detroit for quality control
- Competitive base pricing with volume discounts
- White-label shipping with custom branding options
Verdict on CustomCat
CustomCat is a reliable US-based POD option for merchants who value fast production, competitive pricing, and diverse printing methods. The 3-day production average and in-house manufacturing give it an edge in quality consistency. The Pro plan is well-priced for sellers doing consistent volume who want lower per-unit costs.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does Printify differ from Printful?
Printify is a marketplace that connects you with multiple print providers, letting you choose based on price, location, and reviews. Printful operates its own fulfillment centers. Printify typically offers lower base costs, while Printful provides more consistent quality control.
Is there a free plan on Printify?
Yes. Printify offers a free plan that includes unlimited product designs, a mockup generator, and support for up to 5 connected stores. You only pay the product and shipping cost when a customer places an order.
Can I switch print providers on Printify?
Yes. You can switch print providers for any product at any time. Printify shows you pricing, production time, and user ratings for each provider so you can make an informed choice.
What printing methods does CustomCat support?
CustomCat supports direct-to-garment (DTG), sublimation, and embroidery printing. This variety lets you offer products with different decoration styles from a single platform.
How fast does CustomCat produce orders?
CustomCat averages a 3-day production turnaround from their Detroit, Michigan facility. Shipping time is additional and depends on the customer delivery destination.
Does CustomCat ship internationally?
Yes. CustomCat ships worldwide from their US-based facility. International shipping times and costs vary by destination, and since production is US-only, international orders may take longer to arrive.