Shopify App Comparison 2026

Recurpay Subscriptions App

4.9471 reviews
VS

Joy Subscriptions App

4.9388 reviews

Which Shopify upsell app increases AOV more? Compare pricing, features, ratings & real merchant reviews for Recurpay and Joy Subscriptions App to find the best fit for your store.

Subscriptions app for recurring payment & fast moving brands

View Full Details

Key Features

  • Quick and easy subscription setup with minimal configuration
  • Automated recurring billing with smart payment retry logic
  • Customer portal for self-service subscription management
  • Flexible discount options for subscribe-and-save programs
  • Detailed subscription analytics and revenue tracking

Verdict on Recurpay

Recurpay offers a solid subscription solution with a focus on simplicity and reliability. It is a good fit for fast-growing brands that need dependable recurring billing without the complexity or cost of enterprise platforms. The pricing is competitive and the feature set covers all the essentials.

Boost subscription & recurring revenue with zero fixed fee

View Full Details

Key Features

  • Zero fixed monthly fee with a revenue-share pricing model
  • Flexible billing intervals and subscription discount options
  • Self-service customer portal for subscription management
  • Automated dunning management for failed payment recovery
  • Analytics dashboard with subscription revenue and churn tracking

Verdict on Joy

Joy Subscriptions is a compelling option for cost-conscious merchants thanks to its zero fixed-fee approach on entry tiers and generous free plan. It covers all the subscription essentials and is ideal for merchants who want to test and grow their subscription model without high upfront costs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens when a payment fails?

Recurpay includes smart payment retry logic that automatically attempts to charge the customer again after a failed payment. It also sends email notifications to the customer to update their payment method.

Can I offer discounts for subscribers?

Yes, Recurpay supports subscribe-and-save discounts on the Growth plan and above, allowing you to offer percentage or fixed-amount discounts to incentivize recurring orders.

Does Recurpay work with Shopify Payments?

Yes, Recurpay integrates with Shopify Payments and other major payment gateways supported by Shopify for seamless recurring billing.

How does the zero fixed-fee pricing work?

Joy charges no fixed monthly fee on its base offerings, instead taking a small percentage of your subscription revenue. This means you only pay as you earn, making it low risk for merchants just starting with subscriptions.

Is there a limit on the free plan?

The free plan supports up to 250 active subscriptions. Once you exceed that limit, you can upgrade to the Standard plan for unlimited subscriptions.

Does Joy include dunning management?

Yes, automated dunning management is available on the Standard plan and above, helping you recover failed payments through automated retries and customer notifications.