Shopify App Comparison 2026

Shopify Collective

4.3245 reviews
VS

Printify: Print on Demand

4.72,957 reviews

Which Shopify upsell app increases AOV more? Compare pricing, features, ratings & real merchant reviews for Shopify and Printify: Print on Demand to find the best fit for your store.

Sell products from other Shopify stores and let them handle fulfillment — no inventory needed.

View Full Details

Key Features

  • Sell products from other Shopify stores with no upfront inventory cost
  • Automatic price, inventory, and order sync between stores
  • Supplier handles fulfillment and shipping directly to your customers
  • Discover and connect with complementary Shopify brands
  • Native Shopify integration with no third-party apps required

Verdict on Shopify

Shopify Collective is a unique and underrated tool for merchants who want to expand their catalog by partnering with other Shopify brands rather than sourcing from overseas suppliers. Since it is built by Shopify, the integration is seamless and there are no additional app fees. It works best for brands with established relationships with complementary Shopify stores.

Create and sell custom products worldwide. You design and sell — Printify prints, packs, and ships.

View Full Details

Key Features

  • Wide selection of 900+ custom products at competitive prices
  • Easy-to-use Product Creator for designing merchandise
  • Global network of print providers for local fulfillment
  • Zero inventory risk — pay only when products sell
  • Support for up to 5 stores on the free plan

Verdict on Printify:

Printify is one of the two dominant print-on-demand platforms alongside Printful, with nearly 3,000 reviews and a 4.7 rating. Its massive product catalog (900+), generous free plan, and global print network make it ideal for POD beginners. The Premium plan at $29/month unlocks 20% discounts that quickly pay for themselves at volume.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Shopify Collective free?

Yes, Shopify Collective is completely free with no app fees or transaction charges. It is included as part of your Shopify or Advanced Shopify plan.

Who fulfills orders on Shopify Collective?

The supplier brand fulfills and ships orders directly to your customers. You never handle inventory — the entire process is automated through Shopify's native integration.

Can any Shopify store use Collective?

Shopify Collective is available to stores on the Shopify plan and above (not Basic). Both retailers and suppliers must be on qualifying Shopify plans to participate.

How does Printify pricing work?

Printify is free to install. You pay the base product cost plus shipping when an order is placed. The Premium plan ($29/month) gives up to 20% off product costs.

Can I choose my print provider?

Yes, Printify lets you compare and choose from multiple print providers for each product, comparing price, production time, and shipping location.