AfterShip Returns & Exchanges vs Shopify Order Printer: Shopify App Comparison (2026)

Key Features

• Branded self-service returns portal with customizable return reasons and policies
• Incentivize exchanges and store credit to retain revenue from returns
• Automated return label generation and shipment tracking for customers
• Smart eligibility rules based on return window, product tags, and order value
• Integrates with major carriers, 3PLs, and warehouse management systems

Verdict on AfterShip

AfterShip Returns & Exchanges is the go-to solution for mid-size to large Shopify stores that want to turn their returns process into a revenue retention engine. Its exchange and store credit incentives are best-in-class, and the branded portal gives a premium feel. The free plan is limited to just 3 returns, so most growing stores will need a paid tier quickly.

Key Features

• Print order documents such as pick lists, invoices, packing slips, etc.
• Preview using real orders and print in bulk or one at a time
• Fully customize customer facing templates with HTML, CSS, and Liquid
• Simple pick list editor to select what fields to show and how they’re organized
• Print in bulk up to 50 orders without going into the app